Anyone know where to find butter pecan extract? I've looked at several stores locally (Hy-vee, Walmart, Costco, Kroger) but haven't been able to find it. Any suggestions of online stores that have good extracts/prices?

Thanks! :)

Try www.olivenation.com

They have either pecan or butter rum. Which might be the better substitute for butter pecan extract in a butter pecan cake recipe?

I would actually use both... the combination sounds lovely...

AI used butter rum Loran oil(I couldn't find butter Pecan and I didn't have time to order it) in a butter Pecan cake and it was so good!