OK Peeps! We have a few cakes up for comment, so don't forget to review them upthread! Also, I just found a spot in my settings about email frequency. If you click on your own profile, you will see a "edit subscriptions" on the left side. Click on that. Toward the bottom of the screen it has 2 options:
Immediate Subscriptions Notifications
This setting controls how many email notifications we send you when a thread is updated and you have an "immediate" subscription.
Send one notification the first time the thread is updated, but no more until the next time I visit the site (default)
Send a notification every time there is an update. This can result in receiving multiple notifications for each subscription in between visits to the site.
I think it defaults to the top selection, so if you want to get a notification for every post, make sure you change it to "Send a notification every time.