Hi! I'm making two different pizza cakes for an anniversary event and I'm having issues with cutouts sticking to the mat I'm cutting on as well as the shapes losing their shape when I try to remove them from the mat. At first I thought perhaps I had too little powdered sugar on the mat and too much Crisco on my hands, but after adjusting those, I'm still having issues.
I'm using DMJ69's MMF recipe, colored a dark red for pepperoni. I made it yesterday and let it rest overnight in the bottom drawer of the fridge. I took it out, cut off a portion, kneaded it until it felt "right", then rolled it out and made circles using a circular fondant cutter. When I tried to slide them off the mat (it's a plastic mat used for rolling out pie dough) with an small offset spatula, they immediately decided to morph into weirdly shaped oblongs.
I smushed them altogether into a ball, kneaded, and tried again, thinking perhaps I rolled it out too thinly, This time I made them a bit thicker -- a smidge under a quarter inch, maybe? They made weirdly shaped oblongs again
I added more powdered sugar when I kneaded and less Crisco on my hands....
Repeated everything. Same thing.
Any thoughts? Should I make them even thicker?
BTW, I'm having the same issue with cut-out mushrooms. The only items not giving me issues are the green MMF for peppers and the faintly magenta MMF for red onion...
Many thanks!
I'm using DMJ69's MMF recipe, colored a dark red for pepperoni. I made it yesterday and let it rest overnight in the bottom drawer of the fridge. I took it out, cut off a portion, kneaded it until it felt "right", then rolled it out and made circles using a circular fondant cutter. When I tried to slide them off the mat (it's a plastic mat used for rolling out pie dough) with an small offset spatula, they immediately decided to morph into weirdly shaped oblongs.
I smushed them altogether into a ball, kneaded, and tried again, thinking perhaps I rolled it out too thinly, This time I made them a bit thicker -- a smidge under a quarter inch, maybe? They made weirdly shaped oblongs again
I added more powdered sugar when I kneaded and less Crisco on my hands....
Any thoughts? Should I make them even thicker?
BTW, I'm having the same issue with cut-out mushrooms. The only items not giving me issues are the green MMF for peppers and the faintly magenta MMF for red onion...
Many thanks!






