Ideas wanted - will you marry me cake

What about a Tiffany's box cake with a ring sitting in it and the lid of the box half way on..... very simple and super cute.

After looking up the Peggy Porchen cake you're talking about. What about a cupcake stand? That way you can do cupcakes with those beautiful roses. AND, a cake that matches with the ring box/ring on it for a topper.

I'm assuming they aren't asking a ton of people? Feels like an intimate thing. Ever see people stack two cake stands on top of each other to make a cupcake stand? That would be pretty, they have some fun stands available now. You could also MAKE a cupcake stand. My gut says to make sure the stand isn't too tall, cuz then the bride to be won't be able to see all the details & the actual ring and ring box on top. So, don't be afraid to arrange the cupcakes on a small stand and then around the base on the table.

You could do large roses on each cupcake. OR, I'm sure you've seen pics here on CC of the sweet little clusters of roses and pearls on cupcakes. Those would be pretty too.

For the topper cake the ring and ring box sounds great. If you go large roses on cupcakes, keep the border of the cake simple & add the same large rose next to the ring box. IF you go with delicate little roses for the cupcakes...maybe make those same little delicate roses and flowers on the bottom border of the topper cake.

Can you pipe or use cutters to write will you marry me on the front of the cake? You could keep it simple directly on the cake or put it on an elegant sign made of fondant.

That's my 4 cents! Good Luck!

To add to your comment about your husband not being that romantic when he proposed...how about this????

My brothers' friend actually cut giant letters out of plywood, painted, and strung a TON of twinkle lights to the words "will you marry me". This entire huge thing was set up in his front yard...so when he brought his lady it was all lit up!

Nuts! AND.....oh so romantic. I can't believe I know that guy!

The ring shouldn't be visible at all. I would do a set of gift boxes (made of cake). Is the cake supposed to be big? I figure this way, you can make small cakes as many presents, and maybe one of the boxes should be hollow, where you can put the ring inside?

In the same Peggy Porschen book where "bed of roses" is, there's also Tiffany-style Sugar Boxes. They're hollow.

I think I also remember another sugar box, with flowers, hollow, more Victorian looking, in another book. But I don't have that book with me.

What about a replica of the ring and ring box that he will be proposing with.

ooooohhhhh, I love that idea too imaginethatnj!

Wait a minute though....is he gonna propose straight away? I mean, she's gonna walk in and see the cake & already know what's going on if the cake is a ring theme?

Is this what you mean imaginethatnj? Don't give it away right away? I would imagine there'll be some "decoy" reason for showing up to party.

I LOVE the hidden ring idea. Maybe a decoy lady at the party could take the bride-to-be over to the cake table & show her how cool her cake display is. The bride-to-be would just be thinking it's girl talk. The fellow could walk over and say..."I think THIS one looks like it's meant just for you...

And then, THAT would be the hollow box with the ring in it. COMPLETE SURPRISE!!! Then, she'd realize the gathering was for her! Soooo, fricken' cool!

Although, you'd need some kind of made up reason for the party that she would buy into. Not sure that that's the cake lady's department. But, I do love the general gift box theme. It doesn't give it away.....

I'm excited to see what you choose to make OP!

That sounds great. I'm sure it'll turn out pretty. I like the "find the box in the cupcakes thing".

Not sure how you would do that HUGE rose. With it being elegant. I'm sure you'll find the right balance.

Hope you can post pics when it's all finished!

Oh I can't wait to see photos of this!! I love romantic things, especially proposals!!

If it were me, I'd bake it in a ring-mold (either Bundt, or angel-food, or whatever).