Cake Central › Cake Forums › Cake Talk › Cookies! › Cookies spread too much
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Cookies spread too much

post #1 of 13
2/13/06 at 7:59am
Thread Starter 
I made choc. chip cookies last night, the same recipe I've used before, and they spread so much! The last time I made them, they were perfect. What could've happened? They were literally flat with lumps in the middle where the choc. chips were!
Reply
Reply
post #2 of 13
2/13/06 at 8:15am
Did you maybe grease the cookie sheet when it was supposed to be ungreased? Sounds like a problem with the shortening to me...but I'm definitely not an expert. This happened to me a couple months ago and it was just a problem with me greasing the cookie sheet when I wasn't supposed to...I think...still kinda early and my brain's not working yet...LoL. I'll remember after I click submit.
www.myspace.com/haileypearlsmom
Reply
www.myspace.com/haileypearlsmom
Reply
post #3 of 13
2/13/06 at 8:27am
a couple of possibilities...

1. not enough flour
2. dough too warm when you put it in the oven (or the cookie sheet was hot)

I always freze my cookie dough for 10-20 minutes before baking 'cause i like thick chewy choco chip cookies... it's also great for cut-out cookies as they hold their shape better!
Reply
Reply
post #4 of 13
2/14/06 at 8:05am
Thread Starter 
thanks for the help! I'm thinking maybe I didn't put enough flour in it. The cookie sheets were room temp, but i might try throwing them in the freezer for 10-20 min beforehand next time. I lubb me some chewy choc. chip cookies!
Reply
Reply
post #5 of 13
2/14/06 at 8:18am
Did you use butter or margarine, and if so was it at room temp or was it melted? I read somewhere, I think on Baking911.com actually, that if the butter is too soft, the cookies will spread more when baking. If that's not the case, then I'd say it was due to there not being enough flour in the batter...
Reply
Reply
post #6 of 13
2/14/06 at 8:25am
Alton Brown did a chocolate chip cookie show once. He demonstrated that if you use butter/margarine the cookies spread and are thin. If you use crisco/buttter flavored crisco - they are thick and chewy. I have found a happy medium - I use 1/2 butter and 1/2 crisco~ Makes a nice chewy (not thin) cookie.
Knowledge is a candle that when shared, doubles the light, but the insecure person believes knowledge is a candle that is diminished when it is split between two wicks.
Reply
Knowledge is a candle that when shared, doubles the light, but the insecure person believes knowledge is a candle that is diminished when it is split between two wicks.
Reply
post #7 of 13
2/14/06 at 8:28am
My non-baking girlfriend took my oatmeal choc chip recipe and called me almost in tears. Her cookies had spread until she had one big gooey mess. I lovingly said, "Miss Betty Crocker, tell me exactly how you made them." It took three phone calls before I got the whole story. She melted the butter instead of softening it and she was 1 cup short on the oatmeal. Duh!

I wouldn't freeze my cookie sheets before putting them in the oven. You might warp them. Not having enough flour was probably your problem. I think the brand of choc chips sometimes affects the outcome also. Cheaper ones don't do as well sometimes.

Diane
Lord, If you can't make me thin, please make my friends fat.
Reply
Lord, If you can't make me thin, please make my friends fat.
Reply
post #8 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:03am
I freeze mine all the time... no problems! You don't leave them for days... just 10-15 minutes.

As for the butter vs margarine vs shortening... margarine will definately give you cookies that spread more as it contains more water that butter or shortening. Unless your recipes specifically says butter or margarine, stick to butter (and margarine does not mean the soft spread stuff... it has even MORE water in it!

Whenever I make choco chip cookies, I always double the recipe and freeze the extra dough... just roll it into a sausage shape (diameter about the same as you'd want a cookie) in a sheet of waxed paper... twist the ends and pop it in the freezer! Then I can make just a couple of cookies... I just cut off (with a sharp, hot knife) individual cookie amounts... plop them on a cookie sheet, and bake 'em up!

BTW... if you're making a big batch of cookies and re-using your cookie sheets, make sure they are cooled before adding the next batch of dough or you'll have the same spread problems.
Reply
Reply
post #9 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:08am
Good advice on the Alton Brown show!
Reply
Reply
post #10 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:13am
Too much spread sometimes has to to do with your baking temperature. Consider what the melting point of butter is. If you used butter in your recipe but didn't bake it at the right temperature this may be why. Often times when I roll out my dough, I use powdered sugar. It absorbs moisture and does not add more flour to the point of toughening your cookie. Also, I often replace butter with shortening in a cookie recipe because there will always be less spread, which is due to the melting point. Just a thought.
Diet later...eat more cake!
Reply
Diet later...eat more cake!
Reply
post #11 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:18am
MelC, if I made extra dough and put it in the freezer, I would have it eaten raw before I ever got around to baking it! icon_lol.gif My weakness!
Lord, If you can't make me thin, please make my friends fat.
Reply
Lord, If you can't make me thin, please make my friends fat.
Reply
post #12 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:30am
I use 4 sheets when making cookies. One in the oven, One with cooling cookies on it, one cooling completely off (with nothing on it) and one that I have ready to go into the oven (already cooled with the dough on it) I have a rythum down and it goes very quickly that way. the cooled off one gets washed before the next batch goes on too - unless I am using parchment paper that day.
Knowledge is a candle that when shared, doubles the light, but the insecure person believes knowledge is a candle that is diminished when it is split between two wicks.
Reply
Knowledge is a candle that when shared, doubles the light, but the insecure person believes knowledge is a candle that is diminished when it is split between two wicks.
Reply
post #13 of 13
2/14/06 at 10:31am
Yeah... I have been known to do that too... icon_redface.gif
Reply
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Cookies!
Cake Central › Cake Forums › Cake Talk › Cookies! › Cookies spread too much