Shells

Your icing is perfect! I love the top. I really like side scrolls.

Critique Subgroup Member: Very, very pretty. Really neat and very well done. The top border reverse shells look a little long. Otherwise, absolutely perfect. Excellent job!

critique subgroup member: WOW I am impressed with how insanely smooth your icing is!! your shells are great but they could have used a bit of shading to add a more realistic look. Your bottom border is great.. nicely spaced and sized, the top border is a bit ragged??

critique subgroup member: This is a nice cake. Your BC is soooo smooth. I think your scrolls are nice, but I see a few places where the icing "broke" or bubbled. The top border is a bit rough looking to me. I love the coral and graham cracker "sand."

CSM: I love the graham cracker sand and your shells look awesome. Nice smooth frosting, it looks great to me

Critique subgroup member: Is this cake filled?? Your sides are perfectly straight and smooth except for a bit of icing overload on the top right edge!! JEALOUS!!!! However, the startip you used for your borders is either way too small or the icing was too thick. Try a #22 or a #32 or better yet a #199 for the bottom shell border. One more thing, I love the graham cracker sand. Looks so real!

Critique group member: Cute design! I think some color would be a nice addition, maybe blue.

CSM: I think you did a wonderful job!..I see the broken shell border but is not a major think..It looks great!

Critique subgroup member: gorgeous gorgeous cake! nice and smooth- I think the borders could have been a bit bigger. other than that- it's perfect :)

CSM: Very nice simple cake. Buttercream is perfect. If you force me to come up with one criticism, maybe I would say the scrolls look a little shaky. Other than that, I love this cake and am going to save to my favs. I'm from Florida and this is a great design for the many beach worshippers down here.

Love this cake :) Love the shells and the smoothness of the cake :) Beautiful!

well I think its "beautiful"...lol, and Im jealous also...very nice work.