The cake was a 10" square and 5" tall (four layers of cake and three of filling).

Critique subgroup member: Square is hard isn't it? Also simple is almost impossible too! I like your tag, bow and color. Your dots are bugging me for some reason and I don't know why, but this is well done and I would be pleased to receive it. BTW tag and board are perfect. Yes, you got the smushed corner but heck you knew it so why did I bring it up? Bad Tiptop57.

critique subgroup member: very impressed with the squareness! nice sharp corners and straight edges!! for me there are a bit too many dots, but dots always send my eyes buggy, so that could just be me?? overall.. great cake!

critique subgroup member: WOW...what an excellent square cake...especially since it is iced in BC. I love the 2 shades of pink. The bow is fantastic. Personally I like the dots. I see some slight flaws in the bc, but they do not take away from this cake at all! Great cake presented beautifully.

Critique Subgroup member: You did a great job with those pesky corners! Your bow is terrific and i love the board - great cake! :)

Thanks everyone for the comments! Yeah, the customer wanted "lots of white polka dots" so there ya go. :?

Critique Subgroup Member:I don't think a little smudge takes anything away fromt his cake- you did a great job on the square corners and your pink is a really nice shade. great work

Critique Subgroup Member: I have so much trouble with square cakes so I am in awe with yours. I also love the shade of pink you used

Critique group member: You did pretty well fore a square cake!THose are reallllllly hard to ice! My only suggestion to be to have done the dots with fondant insteadof BC which might have given it a cleaner look JMHO.

CSM: Great job with the edges and corners; love the pink color and the bow. I think maybe the dots could be a bit larger and spaced more apart.

critique member: I think you did a lovely job of frosting this cake...I really love the colors you chose. I think maybe the dots could have been a little more spaced and I think the bow slighty bigger. Other than that this is a very cute cake!

Thanks everyone. I made a buttercream cake with dots today and went with "larger and more spaced apart" ;-D