40Th Birthday

40Th Birthday on Cake Central

Critique Subgroup Member: 40th Birthday Cake covered in Buttercream with Fondant roses

Comments (7)

on

critique subgroup member: your icing is so perfectly smooth! and I love your whimsy roses. Rope borders are nicely done, very even and consistent. The only thing I can see, is that your cake seems to be larger at the bottom than top, not a nice 90° angle sides to top. but overall beautiful cake.

on

practiceandpatience, i had a ton of problems with the frosting, it was a new recipe I was trying and it just seemed to slide down on me

on

critique subgroup member: This is a really pretty cake. Your borders are perfect...very uniform and consistent. I love the roses and the writing looks nice. Here's a silly critique...the edge of the board is rough in a couple of places. :oops: That is not even worth mentioning! Fantastic cake!

on

Critique group member: Very pretty! I love the roses an dthe rope border looks perfect! This has nothing to with the cake itself but I would recommend using a photo editing software in the future so you can brighten the photo.

on

critique subgroup member: what a wonderful cake! your border and roses are just perfect. I can see slight bulging where you said the icing was giving you some problems, but the beauty of your work totally distracts the eye away from that. great job

on

Critique group member: Love the whimsy roses and you borders are great! Only thing I see is the bottom of the cake, as someone has mentioned earlier, but your overall icing work is so smooth!! Great job!!

on

Critique Subgroup member: What a pretty cake! Your handwriing is perfect! I'm wondering if it is the photo or the cake but the bottom seems bigger. Your smoothness is fantastic!