Lovely smooth frosting and great transfer sheet. Can ya bear with me if I'm a bit picky? Puppies have four toes not five. I don't think you needed the star candy glitter nor the gelatin flowers though. Your pink is lovely but your spacing is a bit uneven. Measure your cake with a ruler and mark the beginning and ending of your scrolls and it will always come out perfect. But all in all it is a fun cake.
Critique Group Member: I can see what tiptop was saying about the toes.. the ones on the left have 4 toes and all but one on the right have 5 toes in the paw prints. Other than the slight spacing issues with the scrolls this is a great cake! :)
Critique group member: Like the others have said I work on making the border more even and although I love the design I think the flowers are unnessary and out of place.
Critique Group Member: I love the pink border on this. It ties in the color of the stars. It's a fun & festive cake. I'm sure your granddaughter loved it.
Yeah - agree your border is off a little. Interesting how we all have different opinions on how a cake should/could be designed - I love the extra touches on this cake (the puppy prints, the confetti, flowers, etc...).
critique group member: I think this cake is very fun and very cute! I like all the little touches. I do agree about the piping needing to be spaced better, but overall a very nice presentation!
I also love the added images to this cake and I'm not sure what Tiptop meant about the toes, as I think those are three seperate feet. I love the image. I would have chosen a smaller border
I love your cute puppy. I love your borders, too. :D
Lovely smooth frosting and great transfer sheet. Can ya bear with me if I'm a bit picky? Puppies have four toes not five. I don't think you needed the star candy glitter nor the gelatin flowers though. Your pink is lovely but your spacing is a bit uneven. Measure your cake with a ruler and mark the beginning and ending of your scrolls and it will always come out perfect. But all in all it is a fun cake.
puppy image is too adorable. Overall is a bit busy. I like the S border, but like tiptop stated, the piping should be of equal size and spacing.
Critique Group Member: I can see what tiptop was saying about the toes.. the ones on the left have 4 toes and all but one on the right have 5 toes in the paw prints. Other than the slight spacing issues with the scrolls this is a great cake! :)
Critique group member: Like the others have said I work on making the border more even and although I love the design I think the flowers are unnessary and out of place.
Critique Group Member: I love the pink border on this. It ties in the color of the stars. It's a fun & festive cake. I'm sure your granddaughter loved it.
Yeah - agree your border is off a little. Interesting how we all have different opinions on how a cake should/could be designed - I love the extra touches on this cake (the puppy prints, the confetti, flowers, etc...).
critique group member: I think this cake is very fun and very cute! I like all the little touches. I do agree about the piping needing to be spaced better, but overall a very nice presentation!
I also love the added images to this cake and I'm not sure what Tiptop meant about the toes, as I think those are three seperate feet. I love the image. I would have chosen a smaller border